Doona vs Evenflo Shyft DualRide: Which Car Seat-Stroller Combination Is Best?

The Evenflo Shyft DualRide is at the CHEAPEST price I’ve ever seen! It’s almost $200 less and comparable to standard car seats (being a 2-in-1 combo). Click here to shop the best price.

Doona vs Evenflo Shyft

If you want a car seat stroller combo, I personally prefer the Evenflo Shyft DualRide over the Doona.

Both products offer similar functionality, but I think the Shyft improves on many of the frustrations parents experience with the Doona, especially when it comes to flexibility, wheel storage, and everyday practicality.

That said, I still believe a traditional infant car seat and stroller combo is the better long-term value for most families.

Two-in-one car seat-stroller combinations are everywhere… but a $500+ car seat?! Let’s break it down.

As a mom of four and a Certified Child Passenger Safety Technician (CPST), I’ve seen just about every car seat and stroller setup out there. Stroller and car seat combos like Doona (and now the Evenflo Shyft DualRide are on many registries these days, and I get the appeal. It’s one of those hot items that feels like it will make your life SO much easier – but will it really?

While the Doona is receiving a ton of attention, I think the Evenflo Shyft is a hidden secret more families need to know about.

Let’s break down everything you need to know about the Doona vs Evenflo Shyft DualRide, what option is my favorite, and the value of the traditional car seat and stroller options.

The Doona and Evenflo Shyft are car seats that are also strollers.

The Doona and Evenflo Shyft DualRide are both car seat-stroller combinations designed for easier transition between driving and walking with a baby. These systems remove the need for a separate stroller that needs to be unfolded to use. With both models, a single click or quick motion releases the wheels, turning the car seat into a stroller.

Doona: The Doona is probably the most popular example of this type of product. Its all-in-one system allows the wheels to fold up into the base of the car seat, transforming it into a stroller in seconds. This one is VIRAL online, being one of the first brands to create this combination, but a lot of brands saw this idea and made it even better.

Evenflo Shyft DualRide: The Evenflo Shyft offers identical functionality to the Doona, but with added flexibility. You can detach the wheels entirely when using it as a car seat, making it lighter and easier to carry. The Evenflo Shyft may not be the first brand to create this combination, but they learned what issues families had with the Doona and made an even better version.

Why families love the functionality of the Doona.

Car seat-stroller combinations like the Doona and Evenflo Shyft are great in specific situations:

Traveling: If you’re flying or taking long road trips, these systems are incredibly convenient because you don’t have to lug around both a stroller and a car seat. When it comes to checking luggage, it ends up being one less item to pay for as well.

Quick Errands: A lot of families like car seat-stroller combinations for quick trips to places like grocery stores or doctor’s appointments where you don’t want to deal with unfolding a classic stroller.

City Living: If you live in a city where you typically call a taxi or rideshare to get around, these products are convenient when it comes to the transition from car to the sidewalk. You don’t need to take off the car seat, fold the stroller, and put it in the trunk of a car that’s not yours. Instead, you just click the wheels closed and belt in the car seat.

However, while these systems are convenient for short-term use, I find they can become impractical as your baby grows. The weight makes it nearly impossible to not use the stroller feature over just carrying a car seat by the handle.

Doona vs Evenflo Shyft Price Comparison

These systems are expensive. There’s really no way around it.

Doona Price

Typically around $550–$600

Evenflo Shyft Price

Typically around: $500–$550

And remember: most babies outgrow these systems around 12–15 months.

Doona vs. Evenflo Shyft

• Flexible Base Options: Unlike the Doona, which requires its wheels to always be attached, the Evenflo Shyft allows you to remove the wheels entirely if you just want to carry the car seat. This gives you a lot more flexibility and provides a truly 2-in-1 experience.
• Wheel Tray For Dirt: One major improvement over the Doona is that it includes a wheel tray designed to keep dirty wheels off your car’s seats. I’m happy Evenflo added this and think it was very smart.
• Installation Flexibility: You can install it baseless (using only a seatbelt), on its base with wheels attached (for quick transitions), or on its base without wheels (for longer drives). This allows for the flexibility you’re looking for when buying a combination like this, especially with a price tag that high.
• Price Point: Speaking of the price, while still expensive compared to traditional car seats or strollers, the Evenflo Shyft tends to be slightly more affordable than the Doona while offering more versatility. 

While I think the Evenflo Shyft is definitely an improvement over the Doona—and better suited for everyday use—it still comes with similar downsides like weight and cost (although less in both categories). Overall, it’s just like the Doona, but without all of the complaints.

Why I Prefer The Evenflo Shyft

While the Evenflo Shyft still has some of the same downsides as the Doona, I think it solves many of the biggest frustrations.

Here’s what I like most:

• The wheel frame can fully detach from the carrier
• The carrier is much lighter without the wheels attached
• Optional wheel wells help keep dirty wheels off your vehicle seats
• It offers more installation flexibility

That said, it’s still not perfect.

The full setup is still heavy compared to a traditional infant car seat, and babies will still outgrow it fairly quickly. While the baseless installation option is nice to have, I don’t necessarily think most families will want to use it regularly since repositioning the wheels underneath the carrier can be cumbersome.

My Honest Take On Car Seat Stroller Combos

At the end of the day, I still personally prefer a traditional infant car seat setup — especially a lightweight baseless infant seat paired with a stroller.

In those early newborn weeks and months, I absolutely understand why families love products like the Doona and Evenflo Shyft. They can make quick transitions feel easier, especially if you’re constantly in and out of the car.

But as babies grow, these systems also get really heavy. Over time, lifting both the baby and the full car seat stroller combo in and out of the vehicle becomes much less practical for everyday life.

That’s why I truly think this comes down to personal preference and lifestyle. If you love the idea of a car seat stroller combo and know you’ll use it often, I think the Evenflo Shyft is the better option between the two. But I also want parents to know there is absolutely nothing wrong with sticking with a standard infant seat and stroller setup either.

But right now, I’m really enjoying the Evenflo Shyft.

While the Doona is not my favorite, I do really like the Evenflo Shyft DualRide. The main reason for this is that I feel like Evenflo heard about a lot of issues Doona users had and made their product fix all of them without a huge price bump. 

Are these car seat-stroller combinations safe?

Both the Doona and Evenflo Shyft meet federal safety standards for infant car seats in the United States when used correctly.

Doona Safety Features

• Anti-rebound protection
• Side-impact protection
• Handlebar functions as an anti-rebound bar

Evenflo Shyft Safety Features

• SensorSafe technology with Bluetooth alerts
• Multiple installation options
• Baseless installation capability
• Traditional base installation
• Anti-rebound base design

One important thing I always remind parents: these products are still infant car seats.

Even though they function as strollers too, babies should not remain in seated car seat positions for extended periods of time. For longer outings, it’s still important to give babies opportunities to stretch and reposition outside the seat.

Why Traditional Car Seats & Strollers Shouldn’t Be Overlooked

While both the Doona and Evenflo Shyft offer some great features—especially for travel—I don’t want anyone to overlook how great a traditional rear-facing car seat paired with stroller can be.

Why I Still Prefer Traditional Infant Car Seats

At the end of the day, I still personally prefer a traditional infant car seat setup.

In fact, for many families, I think it’s still the better option because traditional setups are usually:

• lighter
• easier to carry
• more affordable
• more practical long-term

As babies grow and get heavier, lifting these integrated systems in and out of the car can become exhausting really quickly.

That’s why I truly think this comes down to personal preference and lifestyle.

If you know you want a car seat stroller combo, I think the Evenflo Shyft is the better option between the two. But I also want parents to know they absolutely do not need one of these systems to have a great setup.

For example, pairing an affordable infant car seat like the Graco SnugRide SnugFit 35 with a compatible stroller will give you more long-term value than investing in an expensive all-in-one system that your child will quickly outgrow.

If you’re curious to see some of the top infant car seats on the market, check out my post: Best Car Seat for Newborn: Complete Infant Car Seat Guide.

There is NOTHING wrong with a standard car seat and stroller combo.

Both the Doona and Evenflo Shyft DualRide are innovative solutions for parents who need flexibility when transitioning between driving and walking with their babies. They’re especially great for travel or quick errands—but they do come with some drawbacks like weight concerns and high price points.

If you are considering a 2-in-1 solution, I recommend the Evenflo Shyft DualRide over the Doona any day.

While I see value in these systems and really like the Shyft, I want families to know that standard car seats are just as effective (and often more practical) for everyday use. A standard infant car seat paired with a stroller often provides better long-term value because it's lighter and grows with your child.

Ultimately, whether you choose a high-end travel system like the Doona or Evenflo Shyft—or stick with a traditional setup—the best choice is what fits your lifestyle and budget.